Rep. Paul Seeks Assistance from United Nations in Acquiring RonPaul.com from Loyal Supporters

In a seemingly ironic series of events, former U.S. Congressman and three-time presidential candidate, Rep. Ron Paul, has turned to, of all places, the United Nations, an international organization repeatedly criticized by Rep. Paul throughout his political campaigns, for assistance in acquiring the domain name rights of two websites bearing his own namesake: <RonPaul.com> and <RonPaul.org>.  Even more surprising may be the fact that the Respondents in this case appear to be ardent grassroots supporters of Rep. Paul who initially created the websites during Rep. Paul’s 2008 presidential campaign.

The World Intellectual Property Organization (“WIPO”), one of the seventeen specialized agencies of the United Nations, permits trademark owners to file complaints against domain-name registrants for purposes of obtaining relief or resolving disputes in matters concerning the registration and ownership of domain names.  For example, oftentimes, the Uniform Domain-Name Dispute-Resolution Policy (“UDRP”) procedures will be used to combat cybersquatting or situations where an individual will register a domain name with the bad faith intent to profiteer from the goodwill associated with another’s trademark by selling the rights to the mark owner at an inflated price.

On February 7, 2013, Rep. Paul filed his complaint against several unknown Respondents generally alleging in accordance with UDRP requirements that:

1)      The domain names are identical or confusingly similar to Ron Paul’s RON PAUL trademark;

2)      The registrants have no rights or legitimate interests in the domain names; and

3)      The registrants have registered and are using the domain names in “bad faith.”

The complaint further requests that the two domain names be transferred to Rep. Paul without any form of compensation to the current registrants.

While the complaint fails to allege any federal registrations of the RON PAUL mark, Rep. Paul’s complaint, instead, claims common-law rights to the RON PAUL mark by virtue of its use in the United States and in association with Rep. Paul’s “books, articles, public appearances, and political commentary.”  Even though UDRP procedures do not require successful claimants to obtain federal registrations of their marks, such evidence can be helpful in establishing the complainant’s ownership of the mark.  Notably, a search on the Trademark Electronic Search System (“TESS”) reveals that the rights to a RON PAUL mark once held by the Ron Paul Consulting Company were abandoned in November of 2009 due to a failure to file a Statement of Use of the mark.

Additionally, the complaint alleges a lack of any evidence that the Respondents have actually used the two domain names “in connection with a bona fide offering of goods and services,” that the Respondents only registered the two domain names for the purposes of “selling them to [Rep. Paul] for more than [Respondents’] out-of-pocket costs,” and that “the domain names are being used to sell Ron Paul merchandise by third party vendors which competes directly with [Rep. Paul].”

Many reports indicate that the domain owners initially made an offer to sell the domain name <RonPaul.com> to Rep. Paul prior to his filing of the complaint for $848,000.  The owners subsequently reduced their offer to only $250,000 and were even willing to throw in the rights to <RonPaul.org>.

To date, it does not appear that the Respondents have answered the Complaint or made any further efforts to settle or resolve the matter outside of the UDRP process.

Authored by: Scott A. Meyer and John Sokatch, March 9, 2013.

———————————————————————————–

Chalker Flores, LLP provides business, corporate, litigation and intellectual property legal services to individuals, inventors, entrepreneurs, start-ups, spin-offs, universities, research institutes, and small to large public and private companies and businesses.  Founded by Dr. Edwin Flores and Daniel Chalker, additional partners include Scott Meyer, Chainey Singleton and Tom Jacks.  The lawyers of Chalker Flores, LLP provide big-firm expertise with boutique service and pricing.

If you would like more information about Chalker Flores, LLP, or to schedule an appointment please contact us 214-445-4040 or info@chalkerflores.com.  Please follow us on Twitter at @chalkerflores.

Advertisements